Join for FREE | Take the Tour Lost Password?
Shop deviantART for the
holidays and save BIG!
Click here! :holly:
[x]

deviantART

 

Write better Dialogue by =bekkia:iconbekkia:





"Write Better Dialogue!" she shouted, losing her patience.

So, you want to write better dialogue, eh? Well, I'm going to give you a few pointers on how to make your dialogue come to life. Together, we're going to create a dialogue scene. Our character goes by Anderson and he's stuck at a filling station in Florida. The year is 1949.



Attributing Dialogue

First off, forget adverbs exist. Do it now. I don't want to see them in your dialogue tags ever. Not ever stealthily.

Attributing dialogue can be and usually is done with the standard dialogue tag:

"Hey, uh, have any maps?" Anderson said.

This can also be done with a few other words:

"Hey, uh, have any maps?" Anderson asked.

Steer clear of silly thesaurus derived words like: queried, admonished,  barked, bellowed, chastised, commanded, complained, confessed, countered, crabbed, cried, demanded, disagreed, exclaimed, etc. It doesn't make you sound smart. It makes you sound silly. You know why? Because they're redundant. And all redundancies do is take up space. What's more is that most editors find this to be a sign of young writing, and it won't win you points if your story finds itself in the slushpile.

Dialogue tags can also be in the middle of a sentence:

"Sorry son," the attendant said, "fresh out. Aren't lost, are ya?"

Or in the front:

Anderson leaned against the hood of his pickup. "This place is all oaks and stray mailboxes. Where are the road signs?"

See what I did there? Not a said word in sight. Having an action instead of the dialogue tag can give the scene context and texture that are absent otherwise. Attributing dialogue in this way takes your characters out of the void and puts them in the world you've created, now visible in the mind of the reader.

*And as you'll see demonstrated farther down, you needn't attribute every bit of dialogue. Just attribute often enough so your reader knows what's going on.

And I'll also quote myself from a previous article with:
"Some writers tag dialogue differently, such as in Fight Club, where the narrator’s speech isn’t always in quotes. Dialogue in Cold Mountain is set off by dashes. And she said: it’s perfectly acceptable to introduce dialogue with a colon. Heck, be creative with it, just make sure your reader knows what’s going on."



Fragments, Captain

Park yourself in a park or a coffee shop and really listen to how people talk. that's right, I'm giving you permission to eavesdrop.

One thing you'll learn is that no one speaks perfect English, not even English professors. Even they use fragments sometimes.

"Wish I wasn't."  Anderson looked up the road, through the dust kicked up by the coming storm. "My sister's wedding's tonight."

Many people chop off the pronoun I when it comes at the beginning of a sentence.

"Yeah? Where at?" The attendant folded his newspaper, and looked at Anderson over the rims of his glasses. "Ain't a local, I take it."

The same can go for the pronoun "you".

Also, many people do not use proper grammar, but this doesn't immediately imply they're uneducated. Many grammatical issues are regionally colloquial, such as "ain't" or ending a sentence with a preposition.

"Nah, from Philly." Anderson extended his hand. "Name's James Anderson."

Everyone uses contractions, from the Queen of England to Barry the Walmart greeter. Use them, befriend them, know them. (Just don't go apostrophe happy. Be sure your dialogue is readable.)



Character Through Dialogue (or the absence thereof)

This doesn't mean the attendant would say something like:

"Damn yankee, I'll give you directions!"

Instead:

The attendant unfolded his paper and returned to reading it. "Not sure I can help ya if it's much farther south than here."

"Oh." Anderson let his hand fall to his side. "It's in DeBary." He turned back to his car, but stayed undercover of the station. "She's marrying some McGinley character."

Anderson heard a crumple of paper.

"McGinley who?



We can obviously see the attendant's attitude change twice: once when Anderson says where he's from, and another when he says the name of the groom. Use this sort of subtlety, especially in combination with actions, to convey character.



Using @#$% Profanity

Many stories call for the use of profanity. Let's face it, people swear. In this instance I'm going to use:

"Tom McGinley, know him?"

The attendant swore under his breath. "I know him."

"Yeah?"*

"Bastard's my son."


It's important to know your target audience when it comes to profanity. No f-bombs in children's books, kiddies. Likewise, rugged cowboys don't say "Oh, poo."



Slang ten, bro

So, this part doesn't particularly fit into our little story, but I think it needs to be covered anyway.

People use slang, whether it's as simple as different names of things per region or country or as complex as telling someone to stop butt-dialing you, people use it. However, slang can really date a piece. By all means, use it, because it makes the dialogue seem more realistic, but for gosh sakes do your research. For example, I wouldn't call soda "pop" unless I was making fun of someone. It's more of a northern colloquialism.

Dapper, square-rigged, sharp, and gussied up all mean pretty much the same thing, but they're from different eras. When using a historical setting, dating your work is a good thing. Because Victorians don't say: "Hey, bro, pass the ketsup!"
©2009 =bekkia
:iconbekkia:

Author's Comments

Please post questions if you have them, and I'll try to help you out. I can also provide links to slang dictionaries if you need them. Also, if I need to touch on anything else, please say so.

Original section on dialogue from my Layman’s Guide to Storytelling:

Dialogue
In dialogue, I found my earlier work too wordy, and all the characters sounded the same (unless they stopped pronouncing a particular letter and I left an apostrophe just for kicks). Don’t do that. For the love of god. Even if it sounds like people talking when you read it aloud, that doesn't make it good dialogue. Dialogue should have aspects of real speech, but abbreviated and deciphered for your poor reader.

Most people speak differently. I’m southern. I say ain’t and ya’ll. It happens. But I also have a large vocabulary, so I may say I’m going to cogitate over things or that something has permeated my membranes. What I’m trying to say is that dialogue is a fantastic way to characterize. So have different quirks, sentence lengths, and vocabulary choices that reflect your characters and their surroundings.

“While on dialogue, we must discuss the dialogue tag,” she said. That is a proper dialogue tag. Note there is no adverb in sight. The tone of speech can and should be implicit in the words, so any adverbs are just redundant and silly. Dialogue tags can go on the front of a sentence, or break it in the middle. Shake things up.

Some writers tag dialogue differently, such as in Fight Club, where the narrator’s speech isn’t always in quotes. Dialogue in Cold Mountain is set off by dashes. And she said: it’s perfectly acceptable to introduce dialogue with a colon. Heck, be creative with it, just make sure your reader knows what’s going on.

Critiques


:iconshadowsonwater:
I think this addresses dialogue construction really well, though I wouldn't write off using "silly thesaurus derived words like: queried, admonished, ...exclaimed, etc." These can be used effectively, and within the context of what's being written, can often serve to enrich the emotion of what's being said. Example, a mother chastising her child: "I told you to clean your room Jimmy!" Amanda chastised. Or surprise: "You've gotta be kidding!" Bob exclaimed. Of course, they should be used judiciously rather than in every single dialogue attribution. Maybe suggest finding a balance between using them too little and too much.

I really liked how you showed each example through the continued dialogue between Anderson and the attendant. It's effective in showing how each element fits together, and that those elements can be found in stock standard dialogue.

Clear, concise, and pretty well balanced: I think you did a pretty good job here :D Kudos!
The Artist thought this was FAIR
34 out of 40 deviants thought this was fair.

Thank you for your Critique

You are not logged in.

Comments


love 1 1 joy 0 0 wow 0 0 mad 0 0 sad 1 1 fear 0 0 neutral 0 0
:iconnaoko-the-miko:
I found this extremely helpful!
God bless ya!

--
Yatta! Yatta!
[link]
:iconjuliangreystoke:
I agree with your above critiquer (is that a word? My computer doesn't think so) in that I would not do away with all those "silly thesaurus derived words like: queried, admonished, ...exclaimed, etc." I still use them and find them helpful when a tone has to be set very quickly. Like if a character was injured I might write: "I think the bullet missed the bone," Frank murmured. Indicated to the reader that Frank is probably feeling the effects of said bullet.

But maybe I'm just a noob lol. Anway, I agree with everything else pretty much,- she said after reading through his work. ;)

--
"Hey artists, you got a dolla?...Didn't think so" ~RENT
:iconbekkia:
I'm talking about the silly ones. Stuff like murmured or whispered or shouted can be helpful. Personally, I don't use tags, I use attributions. I generally hate said and it's many forms, but I thought I should put them in there. I only use them to denote tone very rarely, otherwise, they tend to be rather redundant.

PS, I'm a chick. ;)
:iconanavah:
Argh! I fav'd this to critique it today and :devshadowsunwater: beat me to it. The recommendation of eschewing thesaurus driven words jumped right out at me. Anything I say would just be an echo.

Well done.

--
No need to thank me for "Faves" or Watches; however, if you feel the need, please do so in my Shoutbox.

Thank you.
:iconbekkia:
Really? I'm surprised so many people disagree. It is an ultimate pet peve of mine. And most editors see it as a sign of greenness in fiction writing.

But I don't even use said or most of it's counterparts when I write. I do attributions instead of tags, but I didn't think it'd be wise to recommend that to everyone.
:iconanavah:
I understand where you're coming from. Believe me, I've thought "attack of the thesaurus" when reading many things. I think it's just the way you worded it. Take cliches for example, is it really 'best' to avoid them even when sometimes they enhance a work? It's like everything else, don't you think? You have to learn how to master it in such a way that it integrates or enhances gracefully (even if 'in your face' ) as part of the whole vs. sticking out like a sore thumb. (see what i mean? ;) )

I'm definitely with Orwell when he recommends two things: lose a word if you can and if it can be said simply, then say it simply.

--
No need to thank me for "Faves" or Watches; however, if you feel the need, please do so in my Shoutbox.

Thank you.
:iconihedge:
I find this useful and informative. :love:

--
Where sorrow meet a silver resolution,
Where sunshine's gentle and refrains its rays,
Where there is no darkness--only shadow--
That is where I wish to spend my days.
:iconjuliangreystoke:
Sorry for the gender mix-up heh *is embarrassed*. Perhaps I could have figured that out if I had tried a bit harder...or perhaps you write like a guy? I have no idea lol. Wanna know a word I love for this sort of thing, and use seldom because it is just so awesome? Gesticulate. Bam. Awesome. lol

--
"Hey artists, you got a dolla?...Didn't think so" ~RENT
:iconsummernightangel:
:iconbravoplz:
Not only helpful, but fun to read as well!

--
~summernightangel doesn't need a compass to know which way the wind is shining.

Details

May 17
6.3 KB
34.3 KB
150×150

Statistics

87
121 [who?]
1,605 (5 today)
20 (0 today)

Site Map